When I initially first heard “All You Had To Do Was Stay,” the first track on 1989, I had to double check the download was good because Swift’s voice sounded…not at all like her. Then one night as I baked a pumpkin pie (and pumpkin cookies and pumpkin pretzels) for Halloween I listened to the album on repeat 4 or 5 times. I’m still not in LOVE with it but each song has a lyric or two I adore. Here’s a few:
